What to do with urban dropouts…
Saturday, April 5th, 2008I was infuriated when I read this opinion piece in the WSJ advocating that the U.S. drop its H1-B visa cap on high tech workers. The author, Shikha Dalmia, says that the U.S. will lose its competitive edge unless it works harder to attract smart people from other countries to move and stay here. Around the same time, there was a spate of news stories about the extremely high dropout rate in American urban centers - in some places as high as 50%. Some journalists danced around the issue but David Harsanyi of the Denver Post frames the issue bluntly:
This catastrophe is predominantly about minority kids living in inner cities.
So on the one hand, we have American businesses fiercely lobbying for the opportunity to hire more knowledge workers from second world countries like India and China and on the other hand we have American kids who have voluntarily checked out of the labor market and who will in all likelihood burden society until their dying breath.
I have an idea. If we need skilled labor so badly, why can’t we up-skill some of these kids who are dropping out of high school? Why do we need to go halfway around the world to find workers? It is frickin appalling that someone who doesn’t speak English as a first language can come over here and take jobs away from kids who were educated in America.
I realize that I am coming off as a nativist but I don’t give a crap because you know what? Those dropout kids are in a competition, whether they like it or not. They’re not just competing with rich kids from the suburbs. No they’re competing with kids who come from places where there’s no food to eat; kids who will come over here and eat their lunch without a second thought. What the effin eff is going on? How can we have let these kids down so badly? Why can’t our society produce people we can employ?
